From the creators of the critically acclaimed DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story comes the next harrowing instalment in Netflix’s true crime anthology: Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story. Set to send chills down your spine, this series re-examines one of the most debated criminal cases of the 20th century.
With true crime continuing to dominate the streaming world, this upcoming release promises not only shocking revelations but also a powerful reimagining of a story that shook a nation. Here’s everything you need to know before you watch.
What’s the Series About?
Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story offers a chilling retelling of one of the most disturbing family tragedies in modern American history. The series revisits the 1989 murders of José and Kitty Menendez — a wealthy, seemingly picture-perfect couple living in an upscale Beverly Hills mansion — who were brutally shot to death in their own living room. Their killers? Their two sons: 21-year-old Lyle and 18-year-old Erik.
At first, the brothers presented themselves as devastated victims, publicly mourning their parents’ deaths and appearing cooperative with authorities. Their outward grief, however, soon unravelled into suspicion. As detectives began to probe deeper, cracks in the narrative emerged, leading to a shocking confession: the Menendez brothers had orchestrated the killings themselves.
What followed was not just a trial, but a cultural phenomenon. Televised gavel-to-gavel, the Menendez case became a defining moment in American legal history and ushered in the era of true crime as primetime entertainment. But beyond the spectacle, the courtroom proceedings exposed harrowing allegations of long-term sexual, emotional, and physical abuse at the hands of their father, José — claims that would polarise the public and forever change the way society views parricide.
Were Lyle and Erik victims lashing out after years of hidden torment? Or were they cold-blooded murderers seeking to inherit a multimillion-dollar estate? The truth — or what resembles it — remains tangled in legal arguments, psychological trauma, and public opinion.
Netflix’s Monsters dives headfirst into this grey area, peeling back the polished exterior of the Menendez family’s affluent lifestyle to explore what was really happening behind closed doors. With emotionally charged performances and a narrative that doesn’t shy away from the darker elements of the case, the series offers viewers an intimate look into a family implosion that continues to provoke debate more than three decades later.
Whether you’re familiar with the case or discovering it for the first time, this series promises a gripping exploration of morality, trauma, and justice in a media-fuelled world where truth can often be stranger than fiction.
Why This Series Stands Out
Unlike many true crime retellings, this production isn’t content with surface-level storytelling. Instead, it offers:
- A Psychological Focus – The narrative explores how trauma, manipulation, and secrecy shaped the Menendez brothers’ lives.
- Multiple Perspectives – The series avoids one-sidedness, instead inviting viewers to form their own opinions.
- Media Critique – It digs into how the media shaped the public’s perception of the trial and contributed to the mythology around the brothers.
Also Read:
- Adolescence Review: A Netflix’s One-Shot Crime Drama That’s Shaking Up British TV
- Harlan Coben’s Missing You – The Ultimate In-Depth Review & Analysis of Netflix’s Must-Watch Thriller
- Apple Cider Vinegar Review: Unmasking the Scandal Behind the Wellness Craze
Watch the Trailers
Netflix has released two official trailers, each offering a glimpse into the intense psychological drama and courtroom tension the series promises:
- First Teaser – Sets a moody, suspenseful tone and introduces the public spectacle surrounding the case.
- Full Trailer – Provides a deeper look at the family’s disturbing secrets, the brothers’ inner conflict, and the explosive legal showdown.
Meet the Cast: Powerful Performances Across the Board
This star-studded cast brings emotional gravity and nuance to one of true crime’s most infamous stories:
| Actor | Role | Known For |
| Javier Bardem | José Menendez | No Country for Old Men, Being the Ricardos |
| Chloë Sevigny | Kitty Menendez | FEUD, American Horror Story |
| Nicholas Chavez | Lyle Menendez | General Hospital |
| Cooper Koch | Erik Menendez | They/Them |
| Nathan Lane | Dominick Dunne | The Birdcage, The Producers |
| Ari Graynor | Leslie Abramson (Erik’s lawyer) | Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist |
| Leslie Grossman | Judalon Smyth (key witness) | American Horror Story |
With experienced performers at the helm, early reviews suggest the acting is nothing short of award-worthy.
Critical Acclaim and Awards Buzz
Even before its official premiere, the series has already generated major awards buzz, thanks in large part to its stellar writing and performances:
🏆 Golden Globe Nominations
- Best Limited Series
- Best Actor – Cooper Koch
- Best Supporting Actor – Javier Bardem
🏆 SAG Nomination
- Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor – Javier Bardem
Expect to see this show making headlines throughout the awards season.
Release Date & Where to Watch
📅 Premiere Date: 19th September 2024
📺 Available on: Netflix (Worldwide)
Be sure to add it to your watchlist – this series is poised to be one of the most talked-about titles of the year.
Should You Watch It?
If you’re drawn to psychological thrillers, courtroom drama, or true crime stories that go beyond the headlines, Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story is essential viewing. With its compelling storytelling, haunting subject matter, and top-tier performances, this Netflix series promises to leave a lasting impression.
